Acceptance for admission to SMI will be based on the whole-man evaluation concept. This concept of evaluation takes into account not only demonstrated academic aptitude, but also demonstrated leadership potential, demonstrated moral convictions, and community service. A prospective cadet should be active in one or more church and civic activities, such as the Boy Scouts, Civil Air Patrol, student government organizations, National Honor Society, and intramural or varsity sports.

Two Character references should be provided by the applicant. These references should be someone who knows the prospective cadet personally and has specific knowledge of the prospective cadet's character and moral convictions. Examples of good references are Church leaders, teachers, employers, coaches, or Alumni of VMI, The Citadel, or West Point.